Honesty
June 8th, 2007 June 8th, 2007 Posted in Personal Anecdotes, ReflectionsNo Comments »
Current mood:
sore
The Hope Lutheran church choir is performing Vivaldi’s Antiphonal Gloria a few weeks from now. It is for double choir but we don’t have enough people, so this little girl Sara is taking the second part with her trumpet. Sara is in the 6th grade I think, and is very good for her age; I get the impression she plays the work perfectly while practicing. In front of us, though, she makes mistakes, and they are the sort engendered by performance anxiety - long flawless stretches, followed by a single wrong note then total collapse. All the little old ladies in the choir are very kind of course; they encourage her, “Oh, Sara, that sounded so nice!”, even when she drops whole sections of the melody.
These ladies are well meaning, but flattery is never good. I’ve gotten the “How nice!” response after screwing up and it makes me want to run from the stage. “Yea, you messed up, but thats alright, try it again” means the audience supports me and wants me to do well. Silence means they may not support me, but there is at least tacit acknoweldgement of the mistake. “That sounded so nice!”, especially after a really hideous error, means they think either:
1) I’m not just bad, I’m so bad I’m not even capable of recognizing how bad I am,
2) I am not only bad but vain and will be pacified by a lie as long as it is complimentary, or
3) That my playing was fine. They have no musical sense and aren’t worth playing for.
Kids get this comment more than adults, perhaps because it is patronizing and adults patronize children as a matter of course. Kids aren’t stupid though. I can see a look of pain on this girl’s face every time someone yells out how great she is - she looks like she’s trying to melt into the stage and disappear. As a child I hated playing for my grandmother because it was, “Oh Matthew, how nice!” no matter what I did. She wasn’t taking my playing seriously and was merely amused because I was cute - I could have banged the keys with my forehead and it would have been “nice”.
My father never let me win at board games, probably for this reason. It’s ok to let kids win as long as they don’t know it, but once they figure it out it destroys their confidence - it shows you don’t have confidence in them. I would have figured it out and I think he knew that.
———————–
Music is such a strange thing. It seems like a metaphor for the whole of life at times, while other times it’s extremely personal and intimate. Improvising with another musician can be especially intimate: I remember auditioning for a band in college, playing blues with this girl I hardly knew, and feeling very exposed afterwards. Just exposed to her though, like she must have known exactly what I thought about her and everyone else after playing with me.
listless
blank
hot Much of my life revolves around art in the broad sense. I earn money at a packaging plant but the art is my real work, and though I am only of middling ability I put alot of myself into it.
calm Doheny is in some ways a pit of immorality and filth, stuffed to overflowing with people bent on it’s wreckage. Hoards of young, indolent Californians gleefully strew the dunes with cigarette butts, bags of pet droppings, beer bottles, and hypodermic needles, while runoff from the city collects in murky rivulets and pools before draining into the ocean.